WebMD / Medscape Showcases the winners of the ‘Meddys’ Film Awards

Why do the Oscars allow for fun?

In honor of this year’s Academy Awards, Medscape and WebMD asked readers to choose the best from the world of movies related to health and performance. More than 250 readers weighed in on more than 50 words and 25 movies to choose from the best pictures of medicine on the shelf.

Readers are not only allowed to choose from the pre -selected candidates, but can also write their favorites.

So, without hesitation, Meddy went to…

Best Medical Movie: Someone flew over the Cuckoo’s nest

Criminal Randle McMurphy (Jack Nicholson) asks to be insane and finds himself outside the prison, but in a room guarded by the Ratched Nurse (Louise Fletcher). The 1975 film won several Oscars, including Best Picture (one of whose producers was Michael Douglas), Best Actor (Nicholson), Best Actress (Fletcher), and Best Director (Milos Forman).

The film received 42%of the vote among our readers, followed by “The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks” (15%), “The Fault in Our Stars” (10%), “The Hospital “(7%).

When he was released, The Hollywood showThe filmmakers and his director were praised, calling the film “a terrifying transformation of the most intelligent man who is pushed to the outer limits of his mind by the need to enforce rules and regulations. with hospital rules. “

Drew Ayers, PhD, a professor of filmmaking at the University of Eastern Washington, said the film’s excellent combination reflects the emotions of many times.

“This is the mid -1970s, and the movie is talking about separation and it’s not fair, that’s Randle McMurphy,” he said. “There is this quest for independence, but it hasn’t been achieved, as it were Easy decision or Bonnie and Clyde. ”

Wayne Grody, MD, PhD, doctor of pathology and medicine, pediatrics, and human genetics at the UCLA School of Medicine and frequent consultant for films and TV shows such as along with CSIunderstand the overall winner’s appeal.

“Of course, it’s normal. It’s considered one of the greatest films ever made by director Milos Forman, ”he said.“ According to Ken Kesey’s original text, the film embodies that kind of sensationalized, magic realism. slant to take from the real show psychiatry to something else in Hollywood – knowing clearly. “

Best Doctor: Robin Williams, Awakenings

To the surprise of many at the time, Williams was not nominated for an Oscar for his work as neurologist Malcolm Sayer, MD. That honor went to his co-star, Robert DeNiro, as patient Leonard Lowe, who received an experimental drug used in catatonic patients. Williams and DeNiro were named Best Player from the National Board of Review.

Awakenings, which received an excellent selection of films, is based on the memoir of the same name by Oliver Sacks, the motivator for the Williams character. When the film was released in 1990, filmmaker Roger Ebert was described as one of Williams “of the best works, clean and pure, with no ugly scandals. which he added at one point – the shtick where it wasn’t called. “

In our election, Williams was the top favorite, with 55% of the vote. Shortly after Jennifer Garner at “Dallas Buyers Club,” followed by Omar Sharif at Dr. Zhivago ”(12%), and Michael J. Fox and“ Doc Hollywood ”(10%).

For Ayers, Williams ’portrayal of the real doctor, as well as the real medicine, combined with a little fictionalization of Hollywood is part of what the film and its works really do.

“[Sacks] He’s a famous doctor and has given confidence, and the real story behind the drugs, ”he said.“ That’s probably the most accurate picture. [of the nominees]. ”

The best nurse: Louise Fletcher, One who flew over the Cuckoo nest

Not only did Fletcher win an Oscar, but also a Golden Globe, as well as honors from the British Academy of Film and Television Arts (BAFTA) for her work as the filmmaker Nurse Ratched in One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest. In his Academy Award speech, he praised the team with the line, “all I can say is I want to be hated by you.”

Our audience also loved Fletcher, with 47% of the vote. Nurse Emily Emma Thompson spent a few seconds on “Angels in America,” followed by Ben Stiller’s work on Greg Focker on “Meet the Parents.”

For Grody, Fletcher’s role stands as a “symbolic moment in film history.”

When the American Film Institute compiled its list of top rated films in 2003, the lead director ranked # 5 behind Hannibal Lecter, Norman Bates, Darth Vader, and The Wicked Witch of the West. In 2018, Fletcher told Vanity Fair that the idea of ​​a nurse would quietly speak up – something that was agreed to by director Milos Forman – and that he created a final story for the nursery. A way that is not shared with anyone today.

“The work was forgotten,” Ayers said. “This picture of a nurse is not a metaphor, but it is forgotten.”

Best patient: Tom Hanks, Philadelphia

Tom Hanks has won the first of his last two Oscars for the role of Andrew Beckett, a Philadelphia married lawyer who was forced to hide his sexuality and HIV-positive status from his colleagues in a law firm. strength. Hanks ’filming of one of the first major films to address the AIDS crisis broke his reputation as a musician, while providing important features of gay films to the general public.

When he received the Trailblazer Award for his contribution in 2015 e Out of the Magazinehistorian Nathan Smith explained the importance of a famous actor playing Beckett: “What Philadelphia Here it is revealed: Tom Hanks gave an eye to the groom. Tom Hanks gives an eye on living with AIDS. Tom Hanks gave an eye to manhood and living with AIDS.

Ayers called Hanks’s filming and the film itself “seriously critical,” in terms of addressing marriage, the AIDS problem, and public awareness – and perhaps even more so. fear – in illness, to stimulate public discussion.

Grody acknowledged that Philadelphia is important for public awareness of people living with HIV / AIDS. “The film portrays people living with HIV and AIDS like everyone else and it’s important that Tom Hanks gets to prove that idea – he just plays kind of grateful. “

Hanks ’work resonates with our public, with 46% calling him the best patient on the screen. Jack Nicholson’s Randle McMurphy from “One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest” got 27% of the vote, followed by Angelina Jolie’s Lisa Rowe in “Girl, Interrupted.”

Best Caregiver: Kathy Bates, Poino

When it came to what our people wanted to keep, Annie Wilkes from the 1990 movie Misery was the top winner with 60% of the vote.

Kathy Bates ’performance against the film is based on a Stephen King story that won her Best Actress Oscar. Wilkes’s fostering of historian Paul Sheldon (James Caan) after a car accident has shown that not everyone is ready to take care of others.

Grody agreed as the best caretaker, Annie Wilkes was the only one to choose. “I don’t know who else you would choose for this division,” he said. “No one can come close to winning this prize.”

Gene Siskel, the last film critic, said Bates ’work elevated the film from being a“ classic thriller ”through his“ amazing work… his neck.

The second last to Bates in our election was Anthony Hopkins’ Dr. Hannibal Lecter from “Silence of the Lambs” (21%) and Gene Wilder’s Dr. Frankenstein from “Young Frankenstein” (13%).

For Ayers, the film isn’t small about conservation, but it’s more about something important today, 30 years after the film’s release: toxic fandom.

“It’s about getting or controlling the image or the product, thinking it’s just ‘for them’ and so it’s worth getting involved,” he said. “This is talking to the media today and how to attack and the producer or writer over something they did because they thought it was for them.”

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.